As he prepared to exit a long-held company, Al Geiwitz discovered how donating privately held stock could reduce taxes and fuel long-term giving.

By Chris M. Garner, Communications Specialist
For more than 40 years, Al Geiwitz has worked as a business investor, acquiring commercial industrial companies with $2-5 million in operating income, developing their leadership and operations, and selling them after increasing their profitability.
Al has invested in more than 30 companies. Over the last 12 years, Al and his company Orion Financial Corp have been co-investing with Stew Stender and his company, Stewart Capital Partners.
“We buy these businesses and hold them long term. We don't sell until our senior managers are ready,” Al said. “We're totally different than private equity groups because our average hold on a business is 15 years.”
Turning a Business Transition into a Philanthropic Opportunity
As business owners approach retirement age, donating a portion of company shares to a donor advised fund can reduce taxable income, provide a charitable deduction, and support causes they care about — all at the same time.
For Al, those considerations came into focus last May during an annual fund review meeting with his Philanthropic Advisor, Nina Graham. As Al shared that he was preparing to sell one of his businesses, the conversation turned to the Foundation’s experience accepting non-cash assets, including privately held stock.
"All of a sudden, Nina knocked on the door when I'm preparing to sell this business,” said Al. “I want to give away more while I'm alive. And I didn’t know if I’d be able to do that.”
By September, after months of coordination with his advisory team — including attorneys, accountants, appraisers and investment bankers — Al was ready to donate his shares of the business to his fund at the Foundation.
“My wife Mary and I strongly believe that we've been blessed to start with little or nothing financially to be able to achieve what we've done — so we're just trying to give back some of what we've been able to grow and earn.”
Al Geiwitz
Before accepting the gift, the Foundation conducted due diligence to ensure compliance and confirm there was a market for the asset. Updated IRS regulations required two separate transactions: first, the donation of Al’s shares to the Foundation, followed by a sale to the buyer. Working closely with Al and his co-investors, the Foundation finalized the sale just in time for year-end.
Within a few months, the value of Al’s privately held stock had been added to his donor advised fund — dramatically expanding his ability to give.
“My wife Mary and I strongly believe that we've been blessed to start with little or nothing financially to be able to achieve what we've done — so we're just trying to give back some of what we've been able to grow and earn,” Al said.
Al and Mary have had a donor advised fund at the Foundation since 2007 supporting organizations including the Basilica of Saint Mary, Hope Centers for Children of Africa, Westwood Community Church and his home church in Minneota, Minnesota, Hope Lutheran — where he created a scholarship fund for local high school seniors.
Al’s Playbook for Donating Privately Held Stock
By donating privately held stock to his donor advised fund, Al was able to reduce his taxable income, receive a charitable deduction, and increase his philanthropic impact — what he calls a “bingo bango” benefit. For other business owners considering a similar path, Al offers three pieces of advice:
- Start planning early; the process can take several months
- Work with an attorney who understands the tax implications of donating privately held stock
- Engage a trusted advisory team (philanthropic advisor, investment banker, accountant, attorney and appraiser)
“If you are of the mind to be charitable, please consider the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation — you can reduce your income and get a tax deduction,” said Al. “I would recommend the Foundation to anyone in my sector donating private stock.”
Partner With Us
Eliminate the complexity of incorporating giving into your business transition plan and give to your fullest potential. Call 651.224.5463 or email us at philanthropy@spmcf.org.
About the Author
As communications specialist, Chris Garner supports the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation’s work by showcasing it to the community through words, photo, video and other media. Chris has a Bachelor of Arts in Communications from Alabama State University and a Master of Science in Journalism from Northwestern University.