Skip to main content

Learn how to incorporate a donor advised fund into your clients’ portfolios to reduce tax drag.

By Mariah Brook, Director of Gift Planning

Mariah Brook, Director of Gift Planning
Mariah Brook, Director of Gift Planning

In order to avoid a “tax drag” it's important to periodically rebalance investment portfolios. This is a basic principle of today’s investment practices and often helps to bring the investment mix back into alignment with the target allocation.

Unfortunately, over time the resulting capital gains tax from rebalancing a non-qualified portfolio adds significant tax drag to the long-term performance. If an investor lives in a state with its own capital gains tax, that tax drag is even greater.

Fortunately, there is a simple strategy that can significantly reduce or even eliminate tax drag – a donor advised fund (DAF).

The vast majority of American households give back to their communities every year. Most of us are in the habit of giving cash to our favorite causes, but there may be a smarter way to give. Gifts of appreciated securities are often a much more financially efficient gift than cash. When combined with a portfolio rebalance, the benefits increase even more.

Kelly’s Investment Story

Let’s look at a hypothetical example to show how it works.

Kelly’s non-qualified investment portfolio is currently valued at $1 million. The target allocation for the portfolio is 60% equities / 40% fixed income, but it currently sits at 65% equities / 35% fixed income. This means Kelly needs to convert $50,000 of equities to fixed income.

She usually donates about $25,000 each year in the form of cash, but this year, her wealth advisor recommended that she consider donating highly-appreciated securities instead of cash in order to make her portfolio rebalancing more tax-efficient.

At her financial advisor's suggestion, Kelly decides to be more strategic with her giving plan.

Kelly contributes $25,000 of highly appreciated stock from her investment portfolio to a DAF. This gift will result in a $25,000 income tax deduction and zero capital gains tax on the donated shares.

She sells another $25,000 to re-invest in fixed income assets. The basis of the stock is zero – resulting in capital gains tax on the entire $25,000. The charitable deduction from the gift of stock essentially off-sets the capital gains tax and virtually eliminates any tax drag this year.

Kelly takes the $25,000 in cash that she planned to donate and adds it to her investment portfolio to purchase the remaining $25,000 of fixed income assets - bringing the balance back up to $1 million.

Rebalance with Gift of CashRebalance with Gift of Securities
Sell $50,000 Securities to ReinvestSell $25,000 Securities to Reinvest
Donate $25,000 in CashDonate $25,000 in Securities
Capital Gains Tax: $50,000 x 20% = $10,000Capital Gains Tax: $25,000 x 20% = $5,000
Add $25,000 Cash to portfolio

Charitable deduction: $25,000 x 35% = $8,750 tax savings

Total tax due: $1,250

Charitable Deduction: $25,000 x 35% = $8,750 tax savings

Total tax due: $0

You may be wondering why Kelly chose to use a DAF rather than donating stock directly to her favorite causes. A DAF at the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation accepts a variety of assets, including securities. Those securities are immediately sold and reinvested into a diversified portfolio. This means Kelly can then recommend grants from her fund to her favorite organizations when she is ready.

She will receive one gift receipt for her gift of securities, rather than multiple receipts if she were to make separate gifts to a variety of causes. This simplifies her record keeping. Kelly’s fund is ready to receive future gifts of securities or other assets she wishes to use for charitable giving. This is just one of the many benefits to establishing a DAF.

Benefits of Partnering with the Foundation

Partnering with us also gives your clients access to a host of other benefits, including:

  • A dedicated philanthropic advisor to help define, plan and fulfill their philanthropic desires

  • Recommendations about the nonprofits and causes that align with their values and desired impact

  • Insights to help them achieve the most impact with their charitable dollars

  • A variety of strong investment options to help them plan for both today and the future

  • Tools to guide individuals and families in defining, setting and executing a bold giving vision

  • Donor-only events, with opportunities to hear and learn about local and emerging topics

  • An online donor portal, making it easy to access information and recommend grants

Contact our team of experts to find out how a DAF can help your clients give smarter. Call 651.224.5463 or email us at

The Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation does not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. Please consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors regarding your individual situation before engaging in any transaction.

More Stories

How to Make Executive Compensation Part of Your Clients’ Charitable Giving

Learn how stock options, executive pay and other compensation could be part of your clients’ giving plan with our quick reference guide to donating executive compensation.

View the guide

Top 5 Reasons to Partner with a Community Foundation

Here are five unique benefits of working with a community foundation to reach your charitable giving goals.

See the Five Benefits

How to Help Your Clients Choose a Donor Advised Fund Provider

See what five factors to consider when choosing a DAF provider as well as how their services compare.

Learn More

Guide Your Clients’ Strategic Giving in High-income Years

Learn how bunching can be beneficial to achieving your clients’ giving and tax goals.

Learn More

Non-cash Assets: Why You Should Talk to Your Clients about Giving Options

Donating a non-cash asset is often more financially beneficial to both your client and the nonprofit they support. The tax benefits can be higher and the non-cash assets are often more valuable.

Find out how

Five Tips to Prepare Your Clients for End-of-year Giving

We’re here to help you and your client meet your year-end goals.

See the tips

Minimize RMD Taxation with a Qualified Charitable Distribution

Now is the time to talk to your clients about options related to required minimum distribution taxation with a qualified charitable distribution.

Learn More

Benefits of Having a Trusted Philanthropic Partner

Learn why attorney Abby Leach Schumaker partners with the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation to help her clients fulfill their giving goals.

Read Abby's story



* Indicates a required field